Remember Me     Forgot Login?   Sign up  

Share this article

fox lane qn revised design publicityThe final design of the Fox Lane QN - Click on the image to download the leaflet

An explanation for the slowness with which measures to implement the Fox Lane "quieter neighbourhood" has been published on the Cycle Enfield website.  On Wednesday the council officer who leads the Cycle Enfield programme will be providing a further briefing at the annual general meeting of Fox Lane and District Residents Association.

In the "letter to residents" (reproduced below) Richard Eason explains some of the complexities of positioning planters at the "neighbourhood gateways" and provides some approximate information about when further planters will be installed.  He also says that measures will be implemented at the junction of Greenway and Meadway to address concerns about speeding traffic cutting the corner (this junction was the site of the "David Burrowes and his Floating Dog" protest meeting in April 2018).

Richard Eason concedes that feedback from residents about the effect of the planters to date has been mixed - apparently no residents have reported any success in reducing traffic or cutting speeds - but says that hard data will shortly be available to supplement the so far anecdotal information.  The baseline data (ie that collected before any planters were installed) will, he says, be uploaded to the website in the near future.

Letter to residents regarding the Fox Lane Quieter Neighbourhood

4 February 2019

Dear Residents of the Fox Lane area,

As you are aware, Enfield Council are in the process of delivering a series of measures in the Fox Lane area as part of the Quieter Neighbourhood project, funded by Transport for London (as part of Cycle Enfield).

The aim of this project is to address shared concerns between both residents and the Council on the speed and volume of ‘rat running’ traffic through these residential streets. At the end of 2017 Enfield Council delivered a consultation on a set of proposals to help address this issue. Following consideration of the responses the Council published a report on the actions it planned to take. The report is available to read here. A key feature of this was to trial the placement of planters at junctions throughout the area. The proposed location of these planters is shown on this map. The concept of the planters is that they will slow traffic passing through the area, creating a less attractive route for ‘rat running’.

Before Christmas, we put out planters on The Mall and Selborne Road as an initial trial and then added two further streets, Old Park Road and Derwent Road, as a result of which we have had a lot of feedback. Some residents have told us that they feel that the planters are reducing traffic. Others have said that they don’t feel that the planters are having any impact at all. Some have said that whilst they’ve discouraged a number of drivers, those that continue to cut through then drive even faster between the planters. Others think the positioning is wrong. Lots of different residents, lots of different views.

In determining the particular positioning of each planter a number of factors need to be considered, which may mean that the exact positioning varies from street to street. Issues to consider include dropped kerbs, utility covers and the extent of existing yellow lines (we have committed to installing planters within the existing yellow lines to prevent a reduction in parking spaces). We also need to ensure that both refuse vehicles and fire appliances can access each residential road and as such we have visited some of the early sites with the London Fire Brigade. Of course, maintaining access to these vehicles does mean that other vehicles of a similar size could still use the road as a cut through. We want to ensure that, for vehicles that do use these streets, the planters are visible and so each planter has a large reflective sign on its front, and reflective strips on each edge.

What we need to do is to collect some additional data on traffic speeds and volume, so we can then compare to the data we collected prior to placing the planters. Before we do this, we are going to install a further set of planters on Amberly Road, The Ridgeway, Oakfield Road, Burford Road and Lakeside Road.  This will result in approximately 50 per cent of the original proposed planters being in place. We will then conduct some interim monitoring to generate further data on speed and traffic volume. We are scheduling this work with our contractors, but hope to have these planters in place within the next four weeks. We will then wait a further two weeks before conducting the surveys. At the same time, we will also be implementing measures at the junction of Greenway and Meadway to address concerns about speeding traffic cutting the corner.

This will enable the Council to have more detailed data in order to consider the next steps. As we outlined in the report, we remain committed to trialling other ideas if the data we gather suggests the planter approach is not having the desired effect.

I appreciate there is frustration with some residents over the time taken to deliver this project, which has included discussion prior to the 2017 consultation. I understand this. However, I would ask for continued patience as we deliver this trial incrementally to best understand the level of impact it is having. At the same time as looking to help address the ‘rat running’ on your streets, we are delivering a series of projects across the Borough, including major investment in the Edmonton area – re-designing some of our streets to ensure they’re fit for the future.

What I hope is clear by the work that we’re doing, is that Enfield Council is committed to tackling the problem of excessive traffic on our residential streets. I hope we can continue to work constructively with the community as we work towards delivering this shared goal.

If you have any questions, in the first instance please send these to my colleague Liz Rhodes, our Community Relations Officer via .

Yours sincerely,

Richard Eason
Cycle Enfield Programme Lead

Note: the baseline data with some improved accompanying explanation will be uploaded here in the next couple of days.

[Source: cycleenfield.co.uk/cycling-news/letter-residents-regarding-fox-lane-quieter-neighbourhood]

Links

Fox Lane quieter neighbourhood - more details (November 2018 report on PGC plus a large number of comments)

Log in to comment

See also...

  • 14 July 2019

Evaporating traffic? The impact of low-traffic neighbourhoods on main roads

A low-traffic neighbourhood scheme would remove through traffic from the neighbourhood's streets, which raises the question: Will the traffic that now drives through the neighbourhood just be displaced onto main roads, causing more congestion? In this article, originally published on the London Living Streets website, the campaign group's vice-chair, Emma Griffin, sets out the evidence, collected over severalyears, which suggests that these fears are overblown.. Read more

  • 19 June 2019

What next for the Fox Lane quieter neighbourhood?

It was standing room only at last week's open meeting of Fox Lane & District Resident's Association (FLDRA) as people from the Association's catchment area (and some from further afield) flocked in, hoping to discover what Enfield Council has in mind for the Fox Lane Quieter Neighbourhood scheme, now that the planters experiment has been officially declared a failure. Actually, we didn't learn much at all about what new traffic calming measures will be proposed, but it was nevertheless a very useful meeting because of what we, the Council and the FLDRA found out about residents' views on traffic volumes and speeds in the so far not very quiet 'quieter neighbourhood' area. Read more

  • 05 June 2019

Planters in Fox Lane area 'not reducing through traffic'

Enfield Council is to end the trial placement of large planters at road junctions in the Fox Lane area because traffic count data collected in May this year shows that the planters are not achieving their intended objective of reducing through traffic. Before trialling an alternative method of reducing through traffic, the council will ask residents to comment on its ideas Read more

  • 30 April 2019

Width restriction introduced on Warwick Road

A new traffic filter in Warwick Road, which local activists see as the first step in a wider effort to implement a Low Traffic Neighbourhood in the west of Bowes Ward, has had a bumpier ride than envisaged Read more