Remember Me     Forgot Login?   Sign up  

Share this article

The consumer group Which? has released its 2017 customer satisfaction survey results for rail companies and Thameslink/Great Northern are almost bottom with some absolutely dire scores.  The numbers in the table below are star ratings (maximum 5 stars).

  Leisure Commuter
Punctuality 2 2
Reliability 2 2
Seat availability 3 2
Standing space 3 2
Frequency 3 1
Carriages 2 1
Toilets 2 2
Value for money 2 2
Customer score 46% 32%

Parent company Govia have predictably blamed strikes for their poor showing.  While strikes have obviously been a major factor for another Govia franchise (Southern - bottom in both tables), there have not been any on Thameslink or Great Northern - unless there have been unreported strikes on Great Northern that are to blame for the daily cancellations, the semi-painted carriages and the failure to wash windows or external surfaces.

govia great northern train at palmers greenA typically scruffy Govia train at Palmers Green

Just contrast the scruffy trains on the Hertford Loop with the very similar trains that TFL Rail run between Liverpool Street and Brentwood.  As soon as TFL Rail took over they refurbished the interiors, adding electronic information displays, and repainted the exteriors, which are kept clean.

The Great Northern trains will be retired some time in 2018, so it's not worth making them attractive?  Well, Govia have had since September 2015 to spruce up the trains, but instead have made them less attractive by removing First Capital Connect branding without repainting the carriages.  The TFL Rail trains aren't long for this world either - they will go when Crossrail services start - but their managers evidently take a bit of pride in what they do.

Which makes it all the more galling that the prospect of eventual transfer of suburban services to TfL that was dangled in front of us a few months ago has now disappeared, seemingly because the government doesn't want to do anything that might boost the popularity of a Labour Mayor in City Hall.

Log in to comment

See also...

  • 10 November 2019

What councils can do to reduce carbon emissions from transport

Nearly two thirds of London councils have declared a climate emergency. While it is relatively straightforward to declare an emergency, it is far more challenging to commit to specific interventions that will deliver big cuts in carbon emissions. The London Living Streets group has identified a range of key policies that local authorities can adopt right now to reduce carbon emissions. All have either been adopted by another major global city, by local authorities in London or elsewhere in the UK. Read more

  • 12 September 2019

Great Northern: 'A great deal of focus on reliability and punctuality'

The managing director of Thameslink & Great Northern Railways has written to London Assembly Member Joanne McCartney apologising for poor service and disruption to her constituents and assuring her that 'there is a great deal of focus by our operations teams on reliability and punctuality'. Meanwhile, in the Twittersphere arguments have been raging about whether or not the new trains are better than the old units Read more

  • 31 July 2019

MP demands better train service amid rising passenger anger and frustration

In response to a flood of tweets from angry and frustrated rail passengers, Enfield Southgate MP Bambos Charalambous has written to the managing director of Govia Thameslink Railway to complain about the continuing high incidence of cancellations due to driver unavailability on routes serving stations in his constituency. Read more

  • 11 June 2019

Govia 'passenger benefits': How about reliable train services?

Palmers Green is one of a long list of railway stations where money for improvements is being made available from Govia Thameslink Railway's passenger benefit fund, which has been set up to provide some sort of compensation to people whose journeys were severely disrupted by the chaotic introduction of new timetables in May 2018. Palmers Green station is in Tier 1 and £80,000 is being allocated. But are GTR yet capable of delivering the most important passenger benefit - a reliable train service? If not, is it high time that the Moorgate services were transferred to Transport for London? Read more